YOUR FERTILITY PHARMACIST

View Original

When the Doctor Says “I Don’t Know”

Your browser doesn't support HTML5 audio

When the Doctor Says, "I Don't Know" Your Fertility Pharmacist

This is one of the few studies that have looked at doctor-patient interactions in the Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) field.

Study Background

Why: with the many knowledge gaps in the relatively new medical field of ART, this study sought to examine how physicians communicate uncertainty to patients

Where/When: eight public and private fertility clinics in Italy, 2013-2015

Who/How/What:

  • 85 videos of medical interactions between an infertile couple and a reproductive physician were collected.

  • One researcher scrutinized 20 of these 85 videos; it is unclear if these 20 videos were randomly selected.

  • Another researcher randomly reviewed 4 of 20 of the twenty watched videos to determine if there was agreement in how the videos were analyzed. Disagreements were resolved by discussion.

  • Five researchers discussed variations of “I Don’t Know” for inclusion/exclusion

    • inclusion = “don’t know”

    • exclusion = “we cannot know,” “how can I know,” and “It is impossible to know this in advance”

  • Videos were microanalyzed for face-to-face dialogue when a physician stated “I don’t know.”

  • Dialogues were translated literally word-for-word from Italian to English.

Results

  • Median # of “I Don’t Knows” per appointment = 2.5 times

    • Male physicians (n = 3) said “I don’t know” 0-3 times

    • Female physicians (n= 7) said “I don’t know” 2-15 times

    • Little difference based on # of years in practice (<15 vs. >15 years experience)

  • Total # of “I Don’t Knows” in 20 videos = 82

    • 73/82 propositional (“conveying negative epistemic stance”)

      • 49/73 for outright lack of knowledge

      • 17/73 uncertainty about terminology or ongoing behaviors

      • 7/73 to obtain information from patient

  • 75% of patients heard their doctor say “I don’t know” and did not remark or question further

    • Patients were most likely to remark or question the doctor when it related to a doctor saying “I don’t know” relating to medical or scientific knowledge their doctor further when the doctor said “I don’t know”

  • More results found within freely-accessible manuscript

Key Takeaways

Study Authors’ Conclusions

  • ART doctors seem prone to transparency when it comes to a lack of knowledge - other medical fields could learn from the ART doctors who disclose uncertainty

  • ART doctors might benefit from specific training on how to disclose unknowns

  • Future studies should also examine non-verbal communication

This Pharmacist’s Conclusions

  • Vanguard study

  • Limitations

    • Unclear if the 20/85 videos selected for viewing were randomly chosen (if not, increased risk of bias towards a certain result)

    • Study results might not be translatable to cultures where conversations follow different linguistic patterns

    • Unclear why 15 years was selected as marker for understanding differences in knowledge based on experience - was this arbitrary?

Resources

Menichetti J, Gerwing J, Borghi L, Gulbrandsen P, Vegni E. Saying "I Don't Know": A Video-Based Study on Physicians' Claims of No-Knowledge in Assisted Reproductive Technology Consultations. Front Psychol. 2021;11:611074. Published 2021 Jan 12. doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2020.611074

Rodriguez, CH. Children’s Hospitals Grapple With Young Covid ‘Long Haulers’. Kaiser Health News. Published March 3, 2021; accessed on March 4, 2021. https://khn.org/news/article/children-covid-long-hauler-clinics-pediatric-hospitals/